J.P. Lestone, J.F. Liang, D.J. Prindle, A.A. Sonzogni, J.P.S. van Schagen and R. Vandenbosch
Recently, Fabris et al.1 have measured
-particles in coincidence
with evaporation residues (ER) in 19F + 181Ta
reactions with beam energies
from 90 to 140 MeV. From these
-data
they concluded the Fermi-gas
level density parameter decreases dramatically from
a = A/8.3 MeV-1 at a thermal
excitation energy of U=20 MeV to a = A/12 MeV-1
at U=100 MeV. Such a sharp
drop in the level density parameter would give a much stronger
increase in nuclear temperature, and thus particle emission rates,
with increasing excitation energy than previously believed. If
true, the claims of Fabris et al. would seriously affect
the conclusions of many recent studies where the properties of
particle emission from hot fissioning systems are used to estimate
the time scales of heavy-ion fission reactions. We have measured
the proton and
-emission
spectral shapes at 90° and 160° to the
beam direction in coincidence with ER from the reactions 150 MeV
and 190 MeV 19F + 181Ta.
Our center of mass spectra are not consistent with
the experimental results of Ref. 1. At 160° to the beam, the
influence of non-equilibrium emission and ER detection efficiencies
on our observed spectral shapes are expected to be small. Fig.
3.7-1 shows our 160° proton and
-spectra converted into the center
of mass reference frame. The solid lines show statistical model
calculations of the corresponding spectral shapes with an inverse
level density parameter K=A/a which increases linearly
with excitation energy from a value of K=8.1 MeV at U=0 MeV to
K=9.2 MeV at U=100 MeV. The standard optical model emission barrier
heights were lowered to reproduce the measured peak positions.
The disagreement at the highest kinetic energies cannot be fixed
with a simple change in the above-mentioned excitation energy
dependence of the level density parameter without producing a
significantly poorer fit to the data in the region several MeV
above the peak positions. The dashed lines show calculations
with the excitation energy dependence of the level density parameter
as suggested by Fabris et al. The dependence of the level
density parameter on excitation energy suggested by our data is
consistent with recent theoretical calculations2,3
while the results
of Fabris et al. are not.
Fig. 3.7-1. Center of mass kinetic energy spectra for proton
and
emission at
lab=160°
in coincidence with ER in 150 MeV and 190 MeV
19F + 181Ta
reactions (solid circles). The solid and dashed lines shown
statistical model calculations (see text).